Post by SeaRat on Jul 13, 2019 20:18:36 GMT -8
I was reading through the Science Diving International, from 1973 book's article, An Attempt to Live Objective and Subjective Performance of Sport Divers' Regulators" by R.J. Nyman and J.G. Van Der Walt, when I happened upon an interesting graph, Figuer 17 (see below):
Non-return valves 001 by John Ratliff, on Flickr
The graph showed the effect of fitting non-return valves in the mouthpiece of a twin hose regulator, a La Spiro Mistral. It showed the same configuration of hoses, first fitted with the Aquastop mouthpiece and second fitted with the Professional Mouthpiece. Then I got to thinking, I have a Professional Mouthpiece, and it's fitted on my DA Aqualung (Broxton) regulator:
DA Aqualung-2 by John Ratliff, on Flickr Note in the background the Hope-Page Mouthpiece, which was then on my Mossback Mk 3 regulator (along with my Suunto dive computer).
Aqualung Regulator-1 by John Ratliff, on Flickr
I have my Mossback Mk 3 fitted with my Hope-Page mouthpiece:
John & Mossback Mk 3-1 by John Ratliff, on Flickr
What would happen if I put this Professional Mouthpiece on my Mossback Mk 3? The Mossback Mk 3 is one of my best-performing regulators, so what would it be like? Well, I did and I dove it yesterday, using my twin steel 52s for the first time in over a year. The results--wow! That does make a difference.
IMG_1167 by John Ratliff, on Flickr
I dove it for over an hour, testing it in various positions. I flooded it and then cleared it by initiating a free flow and exhaling while turning on my left side without problems. A little later I again took it out of my mouth, and switched to my Calypso second stage, then switched back and cleared it manually by blowing into it with my head turned slightly to the right (putting it left-side down), then rolling onto my back while exhaling without problems. The breathing stayed the same, almost effortless. I liked it better than my old USD mouthpiece that I had on it earlier this year, and the mouthpiece on the Hope-Page was pretty good, but the effort slightly worse due to the non-return valves (silicone, but older) in the Hope-Page mouthpiece. The Hope-Page is now on my DA Aqualung (Broxton) and the Professional Mouthpiece is on my Mossback Mk 3.
I did another experiment, actually I was observing the very tiny minnows up-close with my SeawiscopeEY, and found that they were not affected at all by breathing noises. Usually, I have some response, even with the double hose mouthpieces, but this time--no response. I think that the mouthpiece being solid brass may have further dampened the breathing sound for these small criters. I saw several species of minnows, one of which was a black-colored, full-bodied minnow about as big as my thumbnail, and they did not respond at all to my breathing. I had my eyes about three inches away from these small fish in shallow water too.
I went home, and opened my Mossback Mk 3, and to my surprise there was no water in the can itself. Because these hoses are longer, super-stretch hoses, the water never got past the uphill part of the loop so as to enter the box.
All in all, a very promising experiment--the Professional Mouthpiece is staying on my Mossback Mk 3 regulator.
I have a DSV mouthpiece from VDH on my Trieste II, and it needs it as the Venturi is such that the Professional Mouthpiece would allow blow-by.
John
Non-return valves 001 by John Ratliff, on Flickr
The graph showed the effect of fitting non-return valves in the mouthpiece of a twin hose regulator, a La Spiro Mistral. It showed the same configuration of hoses, first fitted with the Aquastop mouthpiece and second fitted with the Professional Mouthpiece. Then I got to thinking, I have a Professional Mouthpiece, and it's fitted on my DA Aqualung (Broxton) regulator:
DA Aqualung-2 by John Ratliff, on Flickr Note in the background the Hope-Page Mouthpiece, which was then on my Mossback Mk 3 regulator (along with my Suunto dive computer).
Aqualung Regulator-1 by John Ratliff, on Flickr
I have my Mossback Mk 3 fitted with my Hope-Page mouthpiece:
John & Mossback Mk 3-1 by John Ratliff, on Flickr
What would happen if I put this Professional Mouthpiece on my Mossback Mk 3? The Mossback Mk 3 is one of my best-performing regulators, so what would it be like? Well, I did and I dove it yesterday, using my twin steel 52s for the first time in over a year. The results--wow! That does make a difference.
IMG_1167 by John Ratliff, on Flickr
I dove it for over an hour, testing it in various positions. I flooded it and then cleared it by initiating a free flow and exhaling while turning on my left side without problems. A little later I again took it out of my mouth, and switched to my Calypso second stage, then switched back and cleared it manually by blowing into it with my head turned slightly to the right (putting it left-side down), then rolling onto my back while exhaling without problems. The breathing stayed the same, almost effortless. I liked it better than my old USD mouthpiece that I had on it earlier this year, and the mouthpiece on the Hope-Page was pretty good, but the effort slightly worse due to the non-return valves (silicone, but older) in the Hope-Page mouthpiece. The Hope-Page is now on my DA Aqualung (Broxton) and the Professional Mouthpiece is on my Mossback Mk 3.
I did another experiment, actually I was observing the very tiny minnows up-close with my SeawiscopeEY, and found that they were not affected at all by breathing noises. Usually, I have some response, even with the double hose mouthpieces, but this time--no response. I think that the mouthpiece being solid brass may have further dampened the breathing sound for these small criters. I saw several species of minnows, one of which was a black-colored, full-bodied minnow about as big as my thumbnail, and they did not respond at all to my breathing. I had my eyes about three inches away from these small fish in shallow water too.
I went home, and opened my Mossback Mk 3, and to my surprise there was no water in the can itself. Because these hoses are longer, super-stretch hoses, the water never got past the uphill part of the loop so as to enter the box.
All in all, a very promising experiment--the Professional Mouthpiece is staying on my Mossback Mk 3 regulator.
I have a DSV mouthpiece from VDH on my Trieste II, and it needs it as the Venturi is such that the Professional Mouthpiece would allow blow-by.
John